VU
Puerto Rican Bullfinch Melopyrrha portoricensis



Taxonomy

Taxonomic note

Melopyrrha portoricensis and M. grandis were previously lumped and listed as Pyrrhulagra portoricensis (del Hoyo and Collar 2016) and before that in the genus Loxigilla following AOU (1998 and supplements); Sibley and Monroe (1990, 1993); Stotz et al. (1996). However, Pyrrhulagra now appears to be a junior synonym of Loxigilla, so the name Melopyrrha is adopted. Monotypic.

Taxonomic source(s)
Handbook of the Birds of the World and BirdLife International. 2022. Handbook of the Birds of the World and BirdLife International digital checklist of the birds of the world. Version 7. Available at: https://datazone.birdlife.org/userfiles/file/Species/Taxonomy/HBW-BirdLife_Checklist_v7_Dec22.zip.

IUCN Red List criteria met and history
Red List criteria met
Critically Endangered Endangered Vulnerable
- - B1ab(ii,iii,iv,v)

Red List history
Year Category Criteria
2022 Vulnerable B1ab(ii,iii,iv,v)
2016 Not Recognised
2012 Not Recognised
2008 Not Recognised
2004 Not Recognised
2000 Not Recognised
1994 Not Recognised
1988 Not Recognised
Species attributes

Migratory status not a migrant Forest dependency medium
Land-mass type Average mass -
Range

Estimate Data quality
Extent of Occurrence (breeding/resident) 9,950 km2 medium
Area of Occupancy (breeding/resident) 9,950 km2
Number of locations 6-10 -
Severely fragmented? no -
Population
Estimate Data quality Derivation Year of estimate
Population size 60000-99999 mature individuals medium estimated 2015
Population trend decreasing - inferred 2017-2028
Rate of change over the past 10 years/3 generations (longer of the two periods) 10-19% - - -
Rate of change over the future 10 years/3 generations (longer of the two periods) 20-29% - - -
Rate of change over the past & future 10 years/3 generations (longer of the two periods) 20-29% - - -
Generation length 3.67 years - - -
Number of subpopulations 1 - - -
Percentage of mature individuals in largest subpopulation 100% - - -

Population justification: This species is described as 'fairly common' (Stotz et al. 1996). The population has been estimated to number 30,000-37,000 pairs (Nytch et al. 2015); this roughly converts to 60,000-74,000 mature individuals. Although it can be difficult to find, it is widespread across Puerto Rico and is common in forests, plantations, and coastal areas at all elevations (Castro-Prieto et al. 2021, Faaborg and Wiewel 2022). Assuming that 60,000 mature individuals is the absolute minimum therefore, the population is suspected to be fairly large, and is placed here in the band of 60,000-99,999 mature individuals.

Trend justification: The species is inferred to be undergoing a moderate decline due to evidence of reduction after hurricanes, which cause severe habitat loss, with the species having limited adaptability to these post-hurricane environments. 

Within its range, tree cover has been lost at a rate of c. 11-12% over the past three generations (11.01 years); since 2016 this has increased to a rate equivalent to c. 25-26% over three generations (Global Forest Watch 2022, using Hansen et al. [2013] data and methods disclosed therein). However, this acceleration in forest loss was largely driven by the impacts of Hurricane Irma and Maria, which hit Puerto Rico in 2017, causing an annual loss of 10-11% (Global Forest Watch 2022). In the years prior to and after these hurricanes, tree cover loss was <1% per year (Global Forest Watch 2022). The species also occurs in a variety of habitats and may be more stable in the lowlands of Puerto Rico (Castro-Prieto et al. 2021, J. Wunderle in litt. 2022), whilst it also frequents protected areas (Faaborg and Wiewel 2022).

However, it is suspected that population declines may accelerate beyond the rate of tree cover loss alone, primarily due to the limited ability of this species to adapt to post-hurricane environments which are invariably increasing due to climate change (Irizarry et al. 2021). After Hurricane Maria in 2017, it is thought that the species is particularly facing declines in the higher elevation habitats of Puerto Ricco, perhaps due to increased cover in ferns and grasses, resultantly leading to limited foraging sites and growth of fruit and seed-bearing trees (J. Wunderle in litt. 2022). Surveys following Hurricane Maria also found that the probability of occupancy and detection had declined in various habitat types (Wunderle 2017, Lloyd et al. 2019, Irizarry et al. 2021); for example, the species had disappeared from over 75 sites by 2018 (Lloyd et al. 2019). Therefore, the population is suspected to be declining at a rate of 20-29% over three generations. This rate may further accelerate in the future as hurricane occurrence increases as a consequence of climate change (Knutson et al. 2010, Walsh et al. 2016).


Country/territory distribution
Country/Territory Presence Origin Resident Breeding visitor Non-breeding visitor Passage migrant
Puerto Rico (to USA) extant native yes

Important Bird and Biodiversity Areas (IBA)
Country/Territory IBA Name
Puerto Rico (to USA) Acantilados del Noroeste
Puerto Rico (to USA) Caño Tiburones
Puerto Rico (to USA) Carite
Puerto Rico (to USA) Ceiba and Naguabo
Puerto Rico (to USA) Cordillera Central
Puerto Rico (to USA) El Yunque
Puerto Rico (to USA) Este Central
Puerto Rico (to USA) Guaniquilla and Boquerón
Puerto Rico (to USA) Humacao
Puerto Rico (to USA) Jobos Bay
Puerto Rico (to USA) Karso del Norte
Puerto Rico (to USA) Karso del Sur
Puerto Rico (to USA) Maricao and Susúa
Puerto Rico (to USA) Salinas de Punta Cucharas
Puerto Rico (to USA) Sierra Bermeja and Laguna Cartagena
Puerto Rico (to USA) Suroeste

Habitats & altitude
Habitat (level 1) Habitat (level 2) Importance Occurrence
Artificial/Terrestrial Plantations suitable resident
Forest Subtropical/Tropical Dry suitable resident
Forest Subtropical/Tropical Mangrove Vegetation Above High Tide Level suitable resident
Forest Subtropical/Tropical Moist Lowland suitable resident
Forest Subtropical/Tropical Moist Montane suitable resident
Shrubland Subtropical/Tropical Dry suitable resident
Altitude 0 - 1300 m Occasional altitudinal limits  

Threats & impact
Threat (level 1) Threat (level 2) Impact and Stresses
Biological resource use Logging & wood harvesting - Unintentional effects: (subsistence/small scale) [harvest] Timing Scope Severity Impact
Ongoing Minority (<50%) Causing/Could cause fluctuations Low Impact: 5
Stresses
Ecosystem degradation, Ecosystem conversion
Climate change & severe weather Storms & flooding Timing Scope Severity Impact
Past, Likely to Return Whole (>90%) Very Rapid Declines Past Impact
Stresses
Species disturbance, Ecosystem degradation, Species mortality

Recommended citation
BirdLife International (2025) Species factsheet: Puerto Rican Bullfinch Melopyrrha portoricensis. Downloaded from https://datazone.birdlife.org/species/factsheet/puerto-rican-bullfinch-melopyrrha-portoricensis on 01/01/2025.
Recommended citation for factsheets for more than one species: BirdLife International (2025) IUCN Red List for birds. Downloaded from https://datazone.birdlife.org/species/search on 01/01/2025.